A link building RFP should force vendors to explain how they operate. If every agency can answer your request with the same polished sales deck, the RFP is not doing enough work.
The goal is to compare processes, not promises. Use the questions below for a formal procurement process or a simpler agency shortlist.
Strategy Questions
- How do you decide which pages should receive links?
- How do you assess our competitors’ backlink profiles?
- How do you determine campaign volume?
- How do you approach anchor-text planning?
- How do you adapt strategy for product, service and commercial pages?
Publisher Sourcing Questions
- What percentage of opportunities comes from fresh outreach, existing relationships or marketplaces?
- Can we approve domains before publication?
- Do you disclose publisher fees separately?
- How do you prevent duplicate placements?
- Do you own, control or have financial relationships with any sites used for placements?
Quality-Control Questions
- What minimum traffic, relevance and authority standards do you use?
- What automatically disqualifies a publisher?
- Do you check domain history and outbound-link patterns?
- Do you evaluate the exact page for niche edits?
- How do you handle sites with high DR but very low organic visibility?
Our publisher quality framework provides a useful benchmark for these answers.
Content and Editorial Questions
- Who writes placement content?
- Can our team review it before submission?
- How are factual or regulated claims checked?
- What happens if the publisher materially edits the article?
Reporting and Durability Questions
- What fields are included in reports?
- How long do you monitor links after publication?
- What qualifies for a free replacement?
- What happens if a publisher changes the link attribute?
Commercial Questions
- What is included in the quoted price and what can create extra charges?
- What are the cancellation, minimum-term and unused-budget terms?
How to Score Responses
Create a simple weighted score rather than choosing the agency with the best sales call. A practical weighting might prioritize publisher quality and transparency first, then strategic fit, reporting, communication and price.
Price should not be ignored, but it should be evaluated after you normalize scope. A $200 placement and a $500 placement are not comparable if one includes custom prospecting, content, approval rights and long replacement protection while the other does not.
Ask for a Paid Pilot
Before a large retainer, request a small paid pilot. The objective is not to get a discount. It is to verify the workflow. Assess how well the vendor follows your brief, how quickly it responds to rejections and whether delivered placements match the standards described in the RFP.
Related Buyer Guides
Use the 15-point link building agency checklist for a faster selection process. If you are still comparing delivery models, read link building marketplace vs agency.
Bottom Line
A strong RFP makes vague providers uncomfortable. That is useful. The best partner should be able to explain how links are sourced, what it rejects, how campaigns are managed and exactly what happens when a placement does not meet the agreed standard.